Cold-water immersion

Also: cold shock, immersion death, circum-rescue collapse

What happens to a body that goes into cold water, in four overlapping stages, and why a life jacket was never enough.

Questions this entry answers

  • What kills people in cold water?
  • How long can you survive in near-freezing water?
  • Did the people of the Wilhelm Gustloff die of hypothermia?

Definition

Cold-water immersion is the body's response to sudden entry into cold water. It is not one process. Modern research describes four overlapping stages: cold shock, cold incapacitation, hypothermia, and collapse around the time of rescue. A person can drown before they ever become hypothermic.

Historical context

Cold water has decided the outcome of shipwrecks, evacuations by sea and river crossings throughout history. Only in the twentieth century did researchers, many of them working for navies and coastguards, separate the stages and show that the old assumption, that people in cold water slowly freeze to death, missed most of what happens.

How it worked

  1. Cold shock, in the first seconds to about three minutes. Sudden cooling of the skin triggers an involuntary gasp and rapid, uncontrolled breathing, and the heart works harder. A gasp with the head under water can be fatal on its own.
  2. Cold incapacitation, from about five to thirty minutes. The hands, arms and legs cool. Grip, coordination and swimming fail. Near 0 °C this can happen in five to fifteen minutes. A person can be fully conscious and unable to hold a rope or climb into a boat.
  3. Hypothermia, often after twenty to thirty minutes. Core body temperature falls below 35 °C.
  4. Circum-rescue collapse. Some people deteriorate while being lifted out of the water or in the hours after. Rescue does not guarantee recovery.

These timings are working approximations, not a clock for any individual. Water temperature, clothing, flotation, waves, injury, exhaustion, body size and the circumstances of rescue all change them.

What it meant for the patient, the soldier, the civilian

For the person in the water, the first minutes are about breathing, not temperature. Then the hands go: the rope is there and the fingers will not close on it. A life jacket keeps a head above water. It does not stop the gasp, it does not keep the cold out, and in waves it does not guarantee a clear airway.

This is why we say the people of the Wilhelm Gustloff died in the water, and not that they all died of hypothermia. Hans Rittner, a navy doctor, reached a lifeboat three-quarters full of water in January 1945 and, in his mediated account, found his hands frozen solid.

Examples from history

  • The Wilhelm Gustloff, 30 January 1945. The sea was near freezing with ice on the surface, and many of the dead died in the water rather than inside the ship. Survivors were pulled out through the night; some did not recover.

Sources

Sources listed
5
Checked against the source
0
Not yet checked
5

Scholarly secondary source

  1. Tipton, M. J. (1989). "The initial responses to cold-water immersion in man." Clinical Science 77, 581–588. View source

    Not yet checked against the source
  2. Tipton, Eglin, Gennser & Golden (1999). "Immersion deaths and deterioration in swimming performance in cold water." The Lancet 354, 626–629. View source

    Not yet checked against the source
  3. Tipton et al. (2017). "Cold water immersion: kill or cure?" Experimental Physiology 102, 1335–1355. View source

    Not yet checked against the source
  4. Shattock & Tipton (2012). "Autonomic conflict: a different way to die during cold water immersion?" Journal of Physiology. View source

    Not yet checked against the source

Reference work

  1. U.S. Coast Guard, National Search and Rescue Supplement, §3.7.2, "Four Stages of Cold Water Immersion."

    Not yet checked against the source

Know a better source or see an error? Send a correction.